“Fair is foul, and foul is fair”
Witches in Macbeth.
One of the definitions of Oxford English Dictionary for the word “sad” is: affected with or expressive of grief or unhappiness. When in the dictionary, this feeling appears to be so rational and controlled but when we think about it and the way we experience this emotion, it could be deep and soul tearing or it could be more like having a fish bone stuck in your heart. It could also be almost imperceptible, like one of those days when you are not particularly cheerful and more in the blue side of your mood. The reasons? A never ending list that varies in importance that could include: a broken heart, the morning news, the departure of a loved one and also a book.
As you already know, there are some books which life wrenching plots bring you to tears, sometimes during the whole book, sometimes at the end of it. In several cases, you knew the story was a sad one beforehand, but in others, sadness strikes when you least expect: the main character of the story dies or something terrible happens that just leave you speechless and teary, even when the book has a happy ending. Nevertheless, you keep on reading because of the beauty of the story.
When I was very young I thought that the purpose of art in all forms, including literature, was to fill my soul with happiness. Later in life I learned that this wasn’t necessarily true and that the goal of a piece of art, in this case a book, wasn’t always linked to the elicitation of joy. I learned then that if I wanted to enjoy beauty in all forms, I shouldn’t be afraid of sadness.
Some examples of beautiful sad books are:
- Paula by Isabel Allende
- Miraculous Journey of Edward Tulane by Kate Di Camillo
- Letter to a Child Never Born by Oriana Fallaci
- Everything is Illuminated by Jonathan Safran Foer
- Patrimony by Phillip Roth
- The Story of Edgar Sawtelle by David Wroblewski
4 comments:
'The Magician's Elephant' by Kate Di Camillo is also a great example of sadness.
As Aristotle said, "The aim of art is to represent not the outward appearance of things, but their inward significance."
~ Jane
Hello Jane
Thanks for giving us another example of a beautiful sad book. I've only read the "Miraculous Journey of Edward Tulane" by this author and I had to confess that at times I couldn't continue reading and I had to put the book aside but it is one of the most beautiful books I've read. Thanks for your comment!!
Another wonderful children's book is Michael Rosen's Sad Book (Candlewick, 2005).
-Joanna N.
Well, on this one the title tells us right there what to expect! :) Thanks for the suggestion!
Post a Comment